Supreme Court decision brings age assurance clarity (U.S.)
June 27, 2025
The U.S. Supreme Court issued its opinion in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, a case challenging a Texas law that requires pornography websites to use age verification measures to prevent minors from accessing harmful content. The Court upheld the Texas law, likely paving the way for similar legislation already enacted or under consideration in more than 20 other states.
While other non-U.S. jurisdictions—such as the U.K. and France—had already adopted similar age verification mandates for pornography platforms, this ruling is significant in the U.S. because of vigorous debates about where age assurance responsibility should be assigned. Online platforms (e.g., Meta, Match Group, Pornhub) and app distribution services (e.g., Apple, Google) have each asserted that the other should bear age assurance responsibility. Various laws imposing requirements exclusively on platforms or app store operators have emerged, both within the U.S. and beyond (Singapore has enacted what is believed to be the first national-level age assurance mandate for app distribution services).
NCMEC takes the position that age assurance should be a shared responsibility, not exclusively assigned to either online platforms or app distribution services. Implementation across the connected ecosystem will best address gaps associated with shared devices, children accessing adults’ accounts, school-issued devices, web browser access to avoid platforms’ apps, etc. A more detailed position statement from NCMEC will be published on the Global Platform for Child Exploitation Policy in the coming weeks.